Evander sinks Orlando City with a brace as Cincinnati wins 1-3 despite being outplayed
Orlando City dominated with 27 shots and six big chances, but Evander's brace and a goal from Gidi gave Cincinnati a 1-3 win that moves it up the East table.

Orlando City controlled the ball, created chance after chance, and still walked away with a 1-3 loss to FC Cincinnati at Inter&Co Stadium. The stat sheet tells one story; the scoreboard tells a completely different one: Evander flipped the script with a penalty and a second goal from open play, and Samuel Gidi put the finishing touch late on.
The match had opened with a script that favored the home side. Martín Ojeda put Orlando City ahead in the 25th minute with a left-footed finish from inside the box after a through ball from Iván Angulo. The 1-0 lead looked fair: Orlando was piling on chances while Cincinnati had barely shown up. But a foul by Marco Pasalic on Pavel Bucha inside the box gave Cincinnati a penalty right before halftime. Evander made no mistake from the spot in the 42nd minute, leveling things at 1-1 heading into the break.
The psychological blow came almost as soon as the second half kicked off. Just four minutes into the restart, in the 49th minute, Evander struck again, this time from open play, with a right-footed shot from the center of the box off an assist from Tom Barlow, making it 1-2. Orlando kept pushing (Martín Ojeda was a constant nightmare for the visiting defense all match long, testing them again and again from inside and outside the box) but couldn't find a way past the Cincinnati goal a second time. And just as the home side's pressure seemed to be building, Cincinnati delivered the killing blow: in the 84th minute, Samuel Gidi curled one into the top corner off an assist from Evander to make it a final 1-3.
Plenty of dominance, not enough finishing
The numbers reveal a clear paradox. Orlando City SC held 57.8% possession, fired off 27 shots to Cincinnati's 10, and created 6 big chances to the visitors' lone one. Yet both sides finished with 8 shots on target, and it was Cincinnati that made its chances count.
| Stat | Orlando City SC | FC Cincinnati |
|---|---|---|
| Possession (%) | 57.8 | 42.2 |
| Shots | 27 | 10 |
| Shots on target | 8 | 8 |
| Big chances | 6 | 1 |
| Corners | 3 | 5 |
| Passes | 581 | 429 |
| Fouls committed | 12 | 14 |
That disconnect between volume of play and result also shows up in the post-match expected goals numbers: Orlando City posted 3.62 xG against Cincinnati's 2.05. In other words, the home team created more and better scoring opportunities, but Cincinnati was far more clinical when it mattered, with Evander as the undisputed star of the show.
Pre-match projections had pointed to a fairly even contest: 47% win probability for Orlando City, 33% for Cincinnati and 20% for a draw, with expected goals split 2.46 for the home side and 2.07 for the visitors. The final result, a clear two-goal win for Cincinnati, flipped that forecast on its head: the model's favorite ended up losing despite dominating nearly every facet of the game except the one that matters most, the scoreline.
What it means in the standings
In MLS's Eastern Conference, Orlando City SC and FC Cincinnati came into this match essentially tied, each with 46 points through 34 games played and no gap separating them before kickoff. Orlando sat eighth with a record of 13 wins, 7 draws and 14 losses, while Cincinnati was ninth with 12 wins, 10 draws and 12 losses. This result gives Cincinnati a clear case for closing the gap in the middle of the table, while Orlando City will have to come to terms with a loss that, given how the game played out, feels like a missed opportunity.
The stat that best sums up the night is big chances: six for Orlando City, just one for Cincinnati. And yet the final score read 1-3. In soccer, sometimes a handful of well-taken chances is all it takes, and that was exactly the lesson Evander delivered with his brace and the final assist for Samuel Gidi.
GET
ATM
ATA
INT
MAR
LEM
ORE
MUR
HUA
UNI
SCL
CIE
ROS
GMD
CAP
REM
RPO
BOL
NSH
CIN
CHI
CLT
VAN
RSL
GDL
CAZ
QRO
NCX
RIV
LAN
INS
HUR
GTI
TRI
FLU
MIR
RBB
VAS
LDU
AUC
COL
CAT
LIM
LAS
FUE
COB
MUN
ANT
MOT
OLI
OLA
THS
BLO
SAB
CAR
OLI
STR
RUB
LIB
MET
DLG
HUL
BHA
LIV
MUN
BAR
VIL
RAC
RSO
OSA
MAL
FCA
M05