FutbolPublished 12 hours ago 4 min read Español

Pochettino's United ledger: who stays and who goes

As he makes his debut against Liverpool chasing his first Premier League win since August, the Argentine is already splitting his squad into two columns: the players he wants to keep and those he plans to move on.

Pochettino's United ledger: who stays and who goes

Mauricio Pochettino arrives at Old Trafford with no time to waste. His first game in charge is nothing less than a trip to Liverpool, and before he can even think about playing philosophy, the Argentine needs something far more urgent: a Premier League win, his first since August. But beneath that immediate fire sits another task, slower and more decisive, one that will come to define his time at United: deciding who stays and who goes from a squad he inherited from six different managers.

Gary Neville told a story recently that captures the coach well: when Pochettino interviewed for the Tottenham job back in 2014, he showed up with a whiteboard split into two columns, the players he trusted and the ones he'd cut loose. That same logic is what he'll now have to apply here, player by player.

In goal and defense, more exits than arrivals

Senne Lammens, 24, keeps his spot in goal despite a dip in form following a costly mistake for Belgium at the World Cup; he's not part of the team's problems. The case of Karl Darlow, 36, signed as a free agent after leaving Leeds, is different: he's well short of the level required to back up at a Premier League giant.

Defense is by far the area with the most departures on the horizon. Diogo Dalot stays thanks to his versatility and the fact he's missed just 18 games through injury since 2020, a reliability that's worth its weight in gold on a squad with so many absences. Harry Maguire, whose contract was just extended by a year, also remains: he lacks sharpness, but brings leadership right as a major overhaul looms at the back. Leny Yoro, only 21, stays for his potential and pace, though he still needs to tighten up defensively. And young prospect Ayden Heaven, with more than 30 first-team appearances, will get another shot to prove he can establish himself, while Harry Amass, 19 and sidelined under Michael Carrick, could finally see minutes under the new manager.

The exits in that unit look set to be significant: Noussair Mazraoui, tried in multiple positions without convincing anyone and with an unreliable injury record; Matthijs de Ligt, who according to Transfermarkt has spent 343 days out injured since arriving in August 2024; Lisandro Martinez, whose contract runs through next summer and who's had a weak season despite sharing a nationality with Pochettino; and Luke Shaw, with 241 Premier League appearances across more than 12 years at the club, whose personal relationship with the coach dating back to their Southampton days doesn't seem enough to save him once his contract expires.

In midfield, Bruno Fernandes is the big dilemma

The captain and the team's best player, Bruno Fernandes, represents the toughest call of all. United has the option to extend his contract another year, through 2028, by which point the Portuguese midfielder will be around 34, but if the plan is a genuine rebuild, it might make more sense to sell him next summer and back a younger alternative instead.

Also marked for the exit are Mason Mount, who has completed 90 minutes in just four league matches since 2023 because of injuries; Andrey Santos, whom Pochettino already loaned out during his time at Chelsea; Manuel Ugarte, short on rhythm and passing range and now also facing an ACL injury that will keep him out until spring; and Patrick Dorgu, who has shown only flashes since arriving from Lecce.

On the positive side, Carlos Baleba, signed for £65 million from Brighton, is shaping up as a key piece once he recovers from his hamstring injury. Youri Tielemans and Kobbie Mainoo also stay for now, though Mainoo will need to earn his long-term place by improving his physicality and speed.

Up front, Cunha and Mbeumo as the benchmarks

In attack, United will keep trying to find a taker for Marcus Rashford, its highest-paid player at £325,000 a week, after neither Aston Villa nor Barcelona turned their loan spells into permanent deals. Joshua Zirkzee and Amad Diallo could also depart, while Matheus Cunha and Bryan Mbeumo have the backing to remain important pieces. Benjamin Sesko, who carries an €85 million buyout clause, needs to regain full fitness after a shin problem, and young Shea Lacey, just 19, is emerging as one of the signs that the club's academy can still deliver.

Comments 0

With your Google, Facebook or Apple account.