New York City FC: 8 games unbeaten against Orlando City SC

Here is the catch: New York City FC's 8-game unbeaten run does not line up with the recent head-to-head results, since Orlando has actually beaten them in March 2026 (0-5), July 2025 and March 2025. Across the full history between these two, New York City FC has 12 wins, 10 draws and 9 losses from 31 meetings, ranging from a 0-5 blowout loss to a tight 2-1 win back in August 2022.